Private Pool Homes on Sanibel Island & Captiva Island
Relax in style with private pool home rentals offering the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and island privacy. Our Sanibel Island vacation rentals and Captiva Island vacation rentals feature beautiful homes with private pools, spacious outdoor areas, and easy access to beaches, dining, and local attractions. Whether you’re planning a family vacation or a peaceful coastal escape, these house rentals provide an unforgettable stay in paradise.
46 properties available
Welcome to "Sea Oats Oasis", a beautiful 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom pool home nestled in the quiet and sought-after Sea Oats community off West Gulf Drive. This raised island retreat offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and location, making it an ideal destination for your next Sanibel getaway.
From the moment you arrive, you\'ll be welcomed by
Sea Oats Oasis
House
$285.00 - $648.00 / per night
4
bedrooms
4
baths
8
guests
5
(1)
Welcome to "Island Sanctuary", a stunning vacation rental property located on Sanibel\'s east end. This tastefully upgraded home features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering a comfortable, open floor plan and living space adorned with stylish coastal decor. Our guests can enjoy the private pool and a large screened lanai, perfect for outdoor relax
Island Sanctuary
House
$233.00 - $592.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(5)
Welcome to "Beach Walk", where coastal comfort meets Island serenity. Come enjoy beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath pool home tucked within the desirable Beachview Estates. Thoughtfully designed with a split floor plan, this light-filled retreat blends relaxed coastal style with comfort and privacy.
Step inside to an airy great room featuring v
Beach Walk
House
$200.00 - $530.00 / per night
2
bedrooms
2
baths
7
guests
5
(7)
Truly island living at its finest! This stunning 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom pool home grants you a luxury vacation experience in a warm and inviting climate only Sanibel has to offer.
Pyrula\'s Palace is located mid-island in the highly sought after Beachview neighborhood overlooking the 9th fairway of the Sanibel Island Golf Club. This well-manicure
Pyrula's Palace
House
$361.00 - $750.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
3
baths
8
guests
5
(5)
"Coastal Charm" has all the island charm you could desire in your next Sanibel getaway! Located in the desirable Shell Harbour neighborhood with deeded beach access and boat dock and canal access right in your backyard! The home boasts 3 bedroom plus a den and 3 bathrooms with a comfortable, open living area with enough space for your whole family
Coastal Charm
House
$233.00 - $440.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
3
baths
7
guests
5
(1)
"Shell Haven" is a beautiful, fully renovated ground level pool home featuring 3 bedrooms/2 baths in the Gumbo Limbo neighborhood. This exquisite home boasts coastal, modern flair and an inviting, open floor plan - great for the whole family. Updated bathrooms and kitchen are sure to please bringing all the comforts of home to your new island oasis
Shell Haven
House
$225.00 - $600.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(2)
Welcome to "Osprey Hideaway" – your perfect island retreat! This charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom ground-level home is located in the highly sought-after Dunes neighborhood on beautiful Sanibel Island. Thoughtfully designed with a spacious split floor plan, there\'s plenty of room for the whole family – including your furry friend! Step inside to f
Osprey Hideaway
House
$214.00 - $555.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
8
guests
Welcome to "Dockside Dream at Ding Darling", an exceptional vacation rental home nestled in a private, oversized setting with direct boating access along the tranquil waters bordering Ding Darling Wildlife Refuge. This architectural beauty offers a perfect blend of elegance and comfort, making it an ideal getaway for families or groups looking for
Dockside Dream at Ding Darling
House
$285.00 - $666.00 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
5
(2)
Welcome to "Five Palms", an exquisite coastal retreat on Sanibel Island. This modern vacation rental offers a serene and luxurious escape, blending style with comfort in every detail.
Featuring 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 beautifully updated bathrooms, this ground-level home has been thoughtfully redesigned to provide a perfect balance of relaxation
Five Palms
House
$233.00 - $592.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
5
(1)
Escape to paradise in this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom home located on a serene canal in the peaceful bay side of Sanibel Island. With direct water access, this home is perfect for those seeking relaxation and adventure alike. Step inside to discover a beautifully renovated space featuring a modern kitchen, updated bathrooms, and styl
Sancroft
House
$261.00 - $666.00 / per night
3
bedrooms
3
baths
7
guests
"Pura Vida" is sure to please!! Don\'t miss this opportunity to enjoy this truly beautiful and spacious home in one of Sanibel\'s premier neighborhoods - Kinzie Island! Located off East Gulf Drive near Sanibel\'s east end, this home is fully furnished and ready to rent! This incredible home boasts 5 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, a beautiful kitchen,
Pura Vida
House
$475.00 - $740.00 / per night
5
bedrooms
5
baths
10
guests
Don\'t miss out on "Castle By The Sea" for your ideal Sanibel Island getaway! This stunning 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom, Mediterranean style home with brand new furnishings throughout is perfect for the whole family!
Long lake views await you at this stunning beach home along with an abundance of living space and new furnishings of island decor. Enter i
Castle By The Sea
House
$250.00 - $648.00 / per night
4
bedrooms
3
baths
8
guests
4
(1)
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Sanibel Vacations
All Rights Reserved.