Rental Properties
71 properties available
Update following Hurricane Ian: This condo sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities INSIDE the unit have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals! Please note: OUTSIDE construction to the Bayside Villa complex and surrounding South Seas resort may be on-going through 2024. On-site construction & work del
Update following Hurricane Ian: We are so very happy to welcome you back to Loggerhead Cay! This condo is now ready for rentals!
Welcome to Loggerhead Cay 242, an island treasure boasting 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and tranquil views of the Gulf of Mexico! This charming condo is nicely appointed and features comfortable coastal furnishings and the ea
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals.
Welcome to "Shimmering Shells" your new island paradise nestled in the beautiful & secluded Sanibel Bayous neighborhood!
This gorgeous west-end home boasts 3 bedrooms plus a
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities inside the home have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals.
"Sooner Beach Escape" is a beautiful, vibrant ground level pool home in the highly sought after East Rocks neighborhood off West Gulf Drive. This home boasts 3
Update following Hurricane Ian:This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and most items & amenities have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals!
Check out "Sandcastle Shores", an incredible 3 bedroom, 2 bath duplex home in the heart of The Dunes golf community featuring lake & fairway views and tranquil beach-style upgr
Update following Hurricane Ian: Welcome back to Mariner Pointe! We are now accepting reservations for the 2025 season.
Mariner Pointe is a great community that offers an array of enjoyable amenities to its guests and has the ideal location with easy on & off access to the Sanibel Causeway and is close to nearby beaches, bike paths, shops & restaur
Update following Hurricane Ian: We are so very happy to welcome you back to Sanddollar! This condo is now ready for rentals starting in January 2025!
Welcome to Sanddollar C101! Totally renovated and updated throughout with custom kitchen cabinetry, stainless-steel appliances and tasteful coastal decor and furnishings. Enjoy unobstructed Gulf view
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals! Inquire directly if interested in a multi-month stay!
Don\'t miss out on this bright, spacious, 2 bedroom 2 bathroom adorable A-frame totally transformed & remodeled home!!
I
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals.
Don\'t miss out on "Castle By The Sea" for your ideal Sanibel Island getaway! This stunning 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom, Mediterranean style home with brand new furnishings througho
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home sustained minimal damages from the storm and all items & amenities have been repaired and/or replaced and it is ready for rentals. Inquire directly if interested in a multi-month stay!
Home amenities include: 3 bedrooms+den/3 bathrooms -- (sleeps 6), WIFI available, Smart TV\'s (streaming only), heated po
Update following Hurricane Ian: We are so very happy to welcome you back to Loggerhead Cay! This condo is now ready for rentals!
Welcome to our island paradise at Loggerhead Cay #174! This gulf-side 4th floor condo boasts stunning Gulf of Mexico views with comfortable coastal updates and furnishings throughout. Featuring 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms wi
Update following Hurricane Ian: This home is a newly built, brand-new construction & it is ready for rentals!
Welcome to "Heron Rest", a true classic beach cottage that\'s been newly built in 2024 for a fresh, clean & comfortable escape - perfect for your next Sanibel rental! This beachside beauty boasts a fully-equipped kitchen with induction c
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.