Loggerhead Cay 274

This unit is top notch! Extremely clean, and everything works perfectly. We have stayed here two years in a row and are vacillating on whether to come back next year. I also want to give a shout out to the Loggerhead Cay complex - a lot of pride in the grounds. The gas grills are excellent. We rented through SBL (Sanibel Vacations) and they handled the booking and setup excellently.

Anonymous from Menomonee Falls - Posted: 2/16/2026

Steve, we truly appreciate your fantastic review! We were delighted to host you again at Loggerhead Cay. We’d also like to give a shout out to Loggerhead Cay; we completely agree that they do an exceptional job and that it is a wonderful complex. Thank you for your kind words about our services; we take great pride in ensuring our guests have a hassle-free and enjoyable vacation experience. We eagerly anticipate your return next year—if not sooner!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We had a wonderful time here. Two adults, plus my 21 and 17 year old daughters. The unit was in great condition, as was the pool and the grounds. I would definitely return if possible someday!

Anonymous from Beverly - Posted: 1/7/2026

Chris, we truly appreciate your fantastic review! We are delighted to hear that you and your family had a wonderful stay and enjoyed the unit. We look forward to welcoming you back again in the near future!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Everything was spot on. The only thing I would suggest is putting grab bars up in both bathroom showers.

Anonymous from Colorado Springs - Posted: 11/23/2025

Dennis and Linda, we truly appreciate you taking the time to share your review! We’re thrilled to hear that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay. Thank you for your valuable feedback about the grab bars; we always welcome suggestions! We look forward to welcoming you back again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

This being our 4th visit to the Loggerhead Cay Condos in Sanibel, FL, we were very pleased with the accommodations of unit #274. The unit was very clean, nicely furnished, and well equipped with everything you would need for a relaxing visit to the Gulf. We loved seeing that the Loggerhead Cay complex has been completely restored since the hurricane, and the surrounding neighborhoods and restaurants are, for the most part, back to normal including those in Captiva. We would definitely recommend staying at Loggerhead Cay Unit #274 for an enjoyable time while visiting Sanibel.

Anonymous from Newtown Square - Posted: 11/16/2025

Dennis, we are thrilled to learn that you had a wonderful stay at Loggerhead Cay 274. Four visits, wowza! You've clearly found your slice of paradise. Thank you for taking the time to share your review; it is truly appreciated. We eagerly anticipate your return for your fifth stay!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Clean, spacious, good amenities, stocked kitchen, prompt customer service.

Anonymous from River Forest - Posted: 3/30/2025

We greatly appreciate you taking the time to leave such a wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay 274! Working with you was an absolute delight, and we can't wait to have you back on the island again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We stayed here the last week of January 2025. The condo was clean, spacious and all the appliances worked well. There were four of us and it accommodated us easily. The property itself was nice, close to the Gulf and well maintained. Loggerhead Cay is close to the Causeway, so getting on and off the island was easy.

Anonymous from Menomonee Falls - Posted: 2/3/2025

Hello Steven, we appreciate you took the time to drop that fabulous review! Thank you! We are delighted that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay, it truly is a pleasant and convenient location. And most importantly, that unit 274 fulfilled all your needs for a fantastic vacation! We look forward to welcoming you back for another relaxing and enjoyable experience. See you soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Loved this beach feeling rental! Tons of memories made last week with our family! Close walk to the pool and beach, and the resort /rental had everything we needed.

Anonymous from Glencoe - Posted: 11/18/2024

Jennifer, we’re delighted to learn that you and your family created such beautiful memories; as the saying goes, "Memories are the treasures we carry with us." We’re thrilled that the unit and Loggerhead Cay provided everything necessary for your “week in paradise!” Thank you for taking the time to share such a wonderful review!

Sanibel Vacations staff

My husband and I brought our young adult son for a week of relaxation at the beach, and this was the perfect place to stay. The condo was beautifully furnished and very comfortable. The owners provided everything you’d need for the beach and the kitchen was well stocked with dishes, etc. We had a wonderful week here!

Anonymous from Zionsville - Posted: 11/10/2024

We are thrilled to hear that you enjoyed a restful vacation. It's wonderful to know that the unit provided all the essentials you needed throughout your stay. Your feedback means the world to us, and it helps us to continually strive to provide the best experiences for our guests. We hope to welcome you and your family back soon for another wonderful getaway.

Sanibel Vacations staff

We had a great experience at loggerhead cay! The condo was beautiful! We felt like we were the first ones to ever stay there. The cleanliness was excellent! We felt Like we were at our own home. We had a wonderful vacation! Than you!

Anonymous - Posted: 9/30/2024

Anne, we appreciate you took the time to drop that fabulous review! Thank you! We are delighted to hear that you had a wonderful experience at Loggerhead Cay. It brings us joy to offer you a clean, comfortable condo where you can fully enjoy the beauty of the island! You were an absolute delight to work with, and we look forward to seeing you again soon.

Sanibel Vacations staff

Very nice, except that the vinyl furniture was falling apart. There were always little piece of white vinyl coming from the dining room chairs. Everything else was exceptional.

Anonymous from Palmetto - Posted: 7/27/2024

Josephine, I truly appreciate you taking the time to share your review! Your feedback is invaluable to us, and we are always striving to improve and provide the best service possible. We’ve taken your advice and have replaced the chairs. Thank you once more, and we can't wait to see you again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

The rental was easy to access, no key to pick up. The rental was very clean, fairly new furnishings. Fourth floor but elevator helped. Everything we needed for beach or pool was there for our use. Exactly as pictured.

Anonymous from Louisiana - Posted: 7/15/2024

Thank you for your review! We are delighted to know that you had a pleasant stay. Hope you'll be back on the island for another vacation soon! Looking forward to seeing you then!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Loggerhead Cay was still receiving love and care to restore storm damage but it was perfect to us! Our unit, 274 was great. Our A/C went out but the issue was promptly taken care of and it wasn't too long before we were cool again.

Anonymous from Church Hill - Posted: 7/1/2024

Jonathan, we are delighted to hear that you had a great stay! Thank you for your thoughtful and positive feedback. We feel fortunate and delighted to have amazing guests like you who are eager to return and enjoy a vacation on Sanibel Island! We look forward to seeing you again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Beautiful condo! When we arrived the plave was clean and looked exactly as posted on the website. This condo has been recently updated and everything looked fresh and new. Just a short walk to the pool, beach, tennis courts, and grills...very convenient. The manager was friendly and quickly handled one small issue (we needed a parking pass for the complexx)). We will definitely return. Highly recommend.

Anonymous from Akron - Posted: 3/17/2024

Thank you Kathy for taking the time out to write such a wonderful review! We're glad to hear you enjoyed your stay with us! We look forward to seeing you again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We were the 1st renters following renovation of the unit after hurricane Ian. The unit was very nice. Furniture was very comfortable. As 1st renters, there was a few items that needed adjustment and the management was very responsive.

Anonymous from GRAND RAPIDS - Posted: 2/18/2024

Steven, we can't thank you enough for the wonderful review! We're so happy you enjoyed your time here on Sanibel Island - we hope to see you again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We had a wonderful experience and was very satisfied with Sanibel Vacations LLC. When we called for bike rentals it was very prompt and friendly experience. We will be using them in the future and we have already pre booked our trip for next year.

Anonymous from Martinsville - Posted: 5/23/2022

Dear Lakrisha, We are thrilled that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay #274 and that it had everything you needed to make your stay a memorable one for all of the right reasons. We work hard to connect the dots before your arrival and during your stay, and we would welcome the opportunity to assist you in planning your next Sanibel vacation.

Sanibel Vacations staff

We had a great time in Sanibel and staying at Loggerhead Cay. The condo we stayed in was great. The kitchen was well stocked with plates, pans, utensils etc. There were plenty of beach chairs and towels. The pool was great, and we even had a little blue heron handing out at the pool one day. I would recommend this condo. It was close to everything, but we were content to stay in and hang out Loggerhead Cay.

Anonymous from Delaware - Posted: 1/31/2022

Dear Linda, Thank you for choosing Loggerhead Cay #274 as your home away from home for your Sanibel getaway. We are thrilled that you enjoyed your time inside and outside. We would welcome the opportunity to assist you in planning your next Sanibel vacation when you are able to return to this very special corner of the world.

Sanibel Vacations staff

This vacation rental was spectacular. Very clean, great location, and everything you need for a week at the beach. I could not get my husband off the chairs in the built in the sun room.

Anonymous from Lonaconing - Posted: 12/13/2021

Dear Donna, We are enlighten to hear that you enjoyed your stay with us in our beautiful Loggerhead Cay Condo! We hope to see you again next year!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We began visiting Sanibel nearly 35 years ago. Over the years, we have stayed at many different locations. Of all our rentals, this was the best stocked of all units. The owners thoughtfully gathered and labeled everything you need for a turnkey beach vacation. Beds were comfortable, space was clean and Loggerhead Cay is always a great location if you want to be near the beach.
My children were ecstatic to see a PlayStation in the unit, Although we never once turned it on because the beach was more appealing! Kitchen was well stocked. So wonderful to have beach towels, chairs and a cooler bag at our disposal. This was the first time we have ever flown and we were concerned we would be without many of our favorite beach items. Thanks to these owners, that was not the case. We will rent again!

Anonymous from Newburgh - Posted: 7/5/2021

Emily, Thank you for the wonderful review of Loggerhead Cay #274! We are so glad you and your family enjoyed your stay. We definitely strive to make vacation rentals feel close to home and we hope to always provide you with everything you need for a wonderful stay. We hope to welcome you back in the future!

Sanibel Vacations staff

Simply Amazing! Everything about Sanibel is wonderful! Thanks Brian & Missy for sharing your home with us! Can't wait to come back!

Anonymous from Candler - Posted: 6/21/2021

Angela, Thank you for the great review of Loggerhead Cay #274! We are so glad you enjoyed your stay at the condo and on Sanibel! We hope to welcome you back in the future!

Sanibel Vacations staff