Loggerhead Cay 242

We loved our stay in Sanibel and at Loggerhead. The condo was perfect for our family of 4, and we were so pleased to find that Sanibel “is back”! Beautiful beach and shelling, awesome pool area, and comfortable accommodations. We would definitely stay here again!

Anonymous from Westford - Posted: 3/8/2026

Overall we had wonderful stay as expected and as announced.
The property is brilliant maintained, safe and The condo itself is nice, need and clean and lovely furnished. The neighbours are adorable and friendly.
A few minor things however have anoid us as it took away some of the indulgence and comfort that we usually found in other locations throughout the 30 recent years.

The most critics is about the king mattress in the masterbedroom, it needs urgently to be replaced. It is old and "through" and doesn't give a relaxing and healthy sleep at night.

Although we love the olde sanibel charme, here it is a bit too much of it here and there, in particular the conditions of the paintwork. In the side bathroom and master bathroom i'ts cracked and inproffesional excecuted.
This is also for the build in cabinets in the bathrooms, in particular in the side bathroom

The patio has no sun protection, so it is barly not usable between morning and early middayhours unless you are searching full sun and strong heat for breakfast. The ventilator is giving barly relief.
The patio furnishing is very impractical as the highchairs and the hightables are far too big for the given space, the provided sunbeds making limited space even more the available. Luckily we are older but sporty people and we could deal with it in a way, but it is hard to envision how handicaped or people with limited mobility will be able use these furniture.

Finally I want to mention the kitchen fit out.
The silverware and the drinking glasses as well as the dishes are very poor and don't fit at all to the general approach nice and tastefull furnished condo. It's a wild mix of everthing, only a few Plastic paltes are provided, Cheap silverware, the random assembled drinking glasses

Having all this mentioned advices I would say that you shouldn't get me wrong, the condo is nice and it is a pleasure to stay there and worth to spend your vacation her

Anonymous from Essen - Posted: 5/19/2025

Harald, we sincerely appreciate you taking the time to share such a thorough review! We are delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay. Your feedback is invaluable to us, and we will certainly take your suggestions into consideration as we make improvements. It's guests like you who help us enhance our services. Thank you once again, and we look forward to welcoming you back soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

We were happy to be back on Sanibel after 2 years. It was our first time at Loggerhead Cay. The apartment and the facilities were very nice and as can be seen in the description and in the pictures.

Anonymous from Filsen - Posted: 12/20/2024

Ursula, we are thrilled that you selected us and Loggerhead Cay for your return vacation to the island! We are even more delighted to hear that you had such a wonderful stay. Thank you for taking the time to share your review; it truly means a lot to us! We look forward to seeing you again soon!

Sanibel Vacations staff

The condo was better than described. It is very close to the beach and pool and in a great location for shopping and restaurants.

Anonymous from Franklin - Posted: 12/8/2024

Rob, we truly value the time you took to share such a wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear that you had a fantastic experience and that you enjoyed the unit. Thank you once again for choosing to stay with us. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we are always here to ensure your visits are memorable and enjoyable. Whether you are returning for leisure or business, we are excited to welcome you back with open arms and continue providing you with exceptional service. Until next time, take care and best wishes!

Sanibel Vacations staff