Sanibel Island & Captive Island Vacation Rentals
110 properties available
"Whimsea" has been beautifully updated and meticulously maintained. This charming Gulf access home is less than a mile from Blind Pass beach. The extensive gardens create a magnificent, private setting. The open floor plan creates a comfortable living area that leads to the spacious screened lanai. The dock and adjacent deck serve as a fabulous wat
Welcome to "Osprey Hideaway" – your perfect island retreat! This charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom ground-level home is located in the highly sought-after Dunes neighborhood on beautiful Sanibel Island. Thoughtfully designed with a spacious split floor plan, there\'s plenty of room for the whole family – including your furry friend! Step inside to f
Don\'t miss out on "Castle By The Sea" for your ideal Sanibel Island getaway! This stunning 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom, Mediterranean style home with brand new furnishings throughout is perfect for the whole family!
Long lake views await you at this stunning beach home along with an abundance of living space and new furnishings of island decor. Enter i
Paradise awaits at Loggerhead Cay #274! This spacious beach front 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom condo on the 4th floor is sure to please the whole family! This eclectic and fun property boasts brand new furniture in the living room and bedroom and offers the convenience of the Gulf of Mexico in your back yard! Loggerhead Cay is a wonderful east end communi
Welcome to our island paradise at Loggerhead Cay #174! This gulf-side 4th floor condo boasts stunning Gulf of Mexico views with comfortable coastal updates and furnishings throughout. Featuring 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms with a sleeper sofa capable of sleeping up to 6 people and offers brand new plank tile flooring, updated kitchen & bathrooms, and a
Welcome to paradise at Sanibel Surfside #213! Listen to the sound of the waves from this stunning & comfortable 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom condo at Sanibel Surfside 213! The impressive entrance welcomes you into an open concept floor plan where partial views of the Gulf of Mexico can be found from the kitchen, dining room, living room and lanai. This be
"Fantasea" is a stunning 4 BR, 3 BA pool home situated on Middle Gulf Drive and is located directly across the street from the Gulf of Mexico!
This island home boasts 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms including an expansive upstairs master retreat. The chef\'s kitchen featuring a gas cook top, stainless steel appliances and adjacent dining area provide
Truly island living at its finest! This stunning 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom pool home grants you a luxury vacation experience in a warm and inviting climate only Sanibel has to offer.
Pyrula\'s Palace is located mid-island in the highly sought after Beachview neighborhood overlooking the 9th fairway of the Sanibel Island Golf Club. This well-manicure
Welcome to your slice of paradise at " Sea Shells & Family Tides", a gorgeous beach front condo at the highly sought after Island Beach Club on beautiful Sanibel Island. This stunning two-bedroom, two-bath condominium offers a perfect blend of relaxed coastal living and modern comfort, just steps from the sugar-white sands and sparkling Gulf waters
Welcome to Bentley Beach House, an exceptional 4-bedroom home in the Gulf Pines neighborhood on Sanibel. For the most discerning traveler looking for a high-end residence with modern features and design elements. Recently renovated with stunning modern upgrades, it features high-end furniture, appliances, exquisite decor throughout, and well-planne
Welcome to "Heron Rest", a true classic beach cottage that\'s been newly built in 2024 for a fresh, clean & comfortable escape - perfect for your next Sanibel rental! This beachside beauty boasts a fully-equipped kitchen with induction cooktop stove, new appliances, and is stocked with all the essential kitchenware items needed to make your favorit
Welcome to "Five Palms", an exquisite coastal retreat on Sanibel Island. This modern vacation rental offers a serene and luxurious escape, blending style with comfort in every detail.
Featuring 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 beautifully updated bathrooms, this ground-level home has been thoughtfully redesigned to provide a perfect balance of relaxation
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.